Debunking Myths About Alternative Lending

Unpacking the Realities of Private Mortgage Solutions to Empower Smarter Financial Decisions and Foster Growth in the Canadian Market

In the dynamic landscape of Canadian real estate, traditional lending avenues don’t always cater to every unique financial situation. This is where alternative lending steps in, offering flexible and tailored mortgage solutions. However, this sector is often surrounded by misconceptions, leading to a lack of understanding and missed opportunities for both individuals and mortgage brokers. 

By dispelling common myths, we aim to clarify the valuable role alternative lending plays in Canada’s diverse financial environment.

Myth 1: Alternative Lending is Only for Those Who Can’t Afford a Loan

Fact: A prevalent misconception is that alternative lending is exclusively a last resort for individuals facing financial hardship or those who have been rejected by traditional banks. In reality, alternative lending serves a broad spectrum of clients, including those with non-traditional income streams, such as self-employed individuals, or those dealing with unique property types that don’t fit conventional lending criteria.

For example, a successful entrepreneur with fluctuating income or a small business owner with significant write-offs might find it challenging to qualify for a traditional bank mortgage, despite being financially robust. With self-employment representing 13.2% of workers in Canada in 2023, encompassing approximately 2.65 million individuals, a significant portion of the workforce falls outside traditional payroll channels. Beyond self-employed individuals, alternative lending is also a vital option for those who are new to Canada and haven’t yet established a long credit history, or for individuals looking to finance unique properties that traditional lenders might deem too niche or risky. 

Alternative lenders offer the flexibility to assess these unique financial pictures, providing solutions when traditional institutions cannot because they often employ more flexible underwriting criteria and take a holistic view of a borrower’s financial situation, rather than relying solely on rigid credit scores or conventional employment verification. This adaptability allows them to assess a broader range of factors, such as property equity, business income, or future earning potential, ultimately opening doors for borrowers who might otherwise be overlooked.

Myth 2: Alternative Lenders Operate Without Regulation or Compliance

Fact: A common and concerning myth is that the alternative lending industry operates in a regulatory “grey area,” implying a lack of oversight and increased risk. This is inaccurate. In Canada, the alternative lending sector, including private mortgage lenders, is subject to a rigorous regulatory framework. Lenders must adhere to provincial and federal regulations, consumer protection laws, and strict ethical standards. For instance, mortgage brokers who work with alternative lenders are regulated by their provincial governing bodies. PHL emphasizes ethical practices and rigorous due diligence in all its dealings. PHL Financial Group Ltd. is also an Exempt Market Dealer, meaning it operates under specific regulatory guidelines for offering certain types of investments, further demonstrating its commitment to compliance.

Myth 3: Alternative Lenders Prey on the Vulnerable

Fact: The idea that alternative lenders exploit individuals in difficult situations is a harmful misconception. Reputable alternative lenders are committed to providing supportive and responsible financial solutions. Their core purpose is to help those with unique situations find financial success by offering flexible financing options that address specific circumstances where traditional banks might fall short. For example, someone going through a divorce or a sudden job change might temporarily have a challenging financial profile that a traditional bank won’t accommodate. Alternative lenders can provide the necessary financing during these periods, allowing individuals to stabilize their finances.

Myth 4: Alternative Lending is Always More Expensive

Fact: While it’s true that interest rates in alternative lending can sometimes be higher than those offered by prime banks, this isn’t a universal truth, nor does it tell the whole story. The perceived “expense” needs to be weighed against the flexibility, speed, and personalized service that alternative lenders provide. For many borrowers, the ability to secure financing quickly, with terms tailored to their specific situation, outweighs a potentially lower interest rate from a traditional lender that may not approve their application or take significantly longer. In a competitive housing market, a rapid approval can be the difference between securing a dream home or losing out. This speed and certainty carry significant economic value, especially when considering that renewals and refinances constituted over 50% of all new mortgage originations in Q4 2024, a 10.6% year-over-year increase. Alternative lenders often have more flexible underwriting criteria, which can save borrowers time and frustration. Ultimately, it proves to be a more cost-effective solution when considering the overall financial picture and opportunity costs, providing clients with flexibility and control over their finances.

Myth 5: Alternative Mortgages are Only Short-Term Solutions

Fact: It’s a common belief that alternative mortgages are solely for short-term needs, acting as a temporary bridge to traditional financing. While they certainly can serve this purpose effectively, many alternative lending solutions are designed with flexibility and long-term financial goals in mind. For instance, a borrower might use an alternative mortgage to consolidate debt and improve their credit score, with the intention of refinancing with a traditional lender in a few years. With total consumer debt in Canada reaching $2.56 trillion in Q4 2024, an increase of 4.6% year-over-year, and credit card balances growing by 7.8% year-over-year, the need for strategic debt management solutions is evident. Open-term mortgage solutions provide clients with flexibility and control over their finances, allowing them to adapt to changing circumstances. With a well-thought-out financial strategy, this is not just a temporary fix but a strategic financial tool. This approach can lead to greater financial prosperity by offering a pathway to managing immediate challenges, seizing opportunities like property investments that require quick financing, or restructuring debt to improve overall financial health. The flexibility of these products allows individuals to navigate fluctuating market conditions or personal financial shifts, ultimately helping them achieve their long-term financial objectives and build lasting wealth.

Connect With Us 

By dispelling these common myths, PHL aims to illuminate the valuable and often misunderstood role that alternative lending plays in the Canadian financial landscape. It’s a sector built on expertise, transparency, and a genuine commitment to client success, offering flexible and effective financial solutions for a diverse range of needs. As the market continues to evolve, understanding the true nature of alternative lending is crucial for individuals seeking tailored financial pathways and for mortgage brokers looking to expand their service offerings. PHL remains your trusted ally, empowering financial success and helping you build a stronger financial future.

If you would like to submit a deal directly, you can do so here. 

Reach out to our team directly: