Understanding Canadian Mortgage Options for Better Decision-Making
Choosing the right mortgage is a vital step in homeownership, and understanding the nuances of different mortgage types can save you money and stress in the long run. With residential mortgage debt in Canada reaching approximately $2.2 trillion as of July 2024, representing a 3.5% increase year-over-year, and federally regulated lenders holding about 80% of this mortgage stock, the decisions made in this market have a significant impact on Canadian households. Among the most common options are open and closed mortgages, each offering distinct advantages.
This article will explore the differences between these mortgage types, and the pros and cons of each. Whether you are looking to pay off your mortgage early or seeking flexibility in your mortgage contract, this guide will help clarify your choices.
What is the Difference Between Open and Closed Mortgages?
Open Mortgages: Flexibility Without Penalty
An open mortgage is a type of mortgage that allows the borrower to make additional payments or pay off the mortgage balance faster without incurring prepayment penalties. This flexibility of an open mortgage can be powerful for homeowners who anticipate receiving lump sums of money, such as bonuses or inheritances, and want to reduce their mortgage balance. Typically, open mortgages come with a higher interest rate compared to closed mortgages. For instance, some published rates in July 2024 showed 1-year open mortgage rates being 1.5% to 2.5% higher than comparable 1-year closed rates. This means that while you have the freedom to pay off your mortgage faster, you may be paying a higher mortgage rate for that privilege. Borrowers who are financially stable and expect to manage their mortgage payments well often opt for open mortgages, as they allow for significant savings in interest over time.
Closed Mortgages: Stability with Lower Rates
In contrast, a closed mortgage is a more traditional mortgage option that does not permit additional payments or early payoff without incurring penalties. Borrowers are usually locked into their mortgage terms until the end of the term, making it difficult to break a closed mortgage without facing financial repercussions. Closed mortgages are significantly more common in Canada due to their typically lower interest rates, which often outweigh the added flexibility of an open mortgage for most homeowners. As of April/May 2025, the lowest available 5-year fixed mortgage rates in Canada are around 3.84%, while the lowest variable rates are around 3.95%. For those who are certain they will not need to pay off their mortgage early, a closed mortgage may be a more financially prudent choice. The lower interest rate can result in lower overall mortgage payments, making it an attractive option for many homeowners.
The Pros and Cons of Open and Closed Mortgages
The key differences between open and closed mortgages can be summarized in terms of flexibility and cost. Open mortgages provide the option to pay off your mortgage early without penalties, but this flexibility comes at the price of a higher interest rate. Conversely, closed mortgages typically feature lower interest rates but restrict additional payments and early payoff options. Understanding these terms is crucial for anyone looking to secure a mortgage, as the choice between an open or closed mortgage can significantly impact your financial situation over the life of the loan.
| Open Mortgages | Closed Mortgages | |
| Pros | – Ability to make extra payments or pay off mortgage balance without prepayment penalties – Save significant interest over time – Flexibility to pay mortgage faster when additional funds are available (benefitting those with fluctuating incomes) – Adaptability in changing economic conditions | – Offers lower interest rates than open mortgages – Fixed interest rates provide consistent and predictable monthly payments – Lower interest rates can lead to less interest paid over the mortgage term – Ideal for borrowers who prioritize stability and predictable housing costs |
| Cons | – Typically come with higher interest rates – Variable interest rates can lead to fluctuating payments, making budgeting challenging – With increased flexibility, there is often a higher overall cost of borrowing | – Lack of flexibility, restricting extra payments or early payoff without prepayment penalties – Potential for higher overall interest payments – Risk of being locked into a higher interest rate if market rates drop |
Which Mortgage Type is Right for You?
The decision between an open or closed mortgage ultimately depends on your financial situation and long-term goals. If you anticipate having extra funds to pay off your mortgage early, an open mortgage may be the most beneficial option, despite its higher interest rate. Conversely, if you prefer lower monthly payments and can commit to the mortgage term without needing to make additional payments, a closed mortgage may be more suitable. It’s crucial to evaluate your financial stability, the current interest rate environment, and your personal preferences when choosing between these mortgage types.
How to Choose Between Open and Closed Mortgages Based on Your Needs
Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Mortgage Type
Choosing between open and closed mortgage options involves several critical factors. Begin by assessing your financial stability and future income prospects. If you expect to have additional funds to pay off your mortgage early or make larger payments, an open mortgage may be the right choice. Conversely, if your financial situation is stable and you prefer the predictability of lower monthly payments, a closed mortgage might be more appealing. Additionally, consider your long-term housing plans; if you plan to stay in your home for a long time, locking in a lower rate with a closed mortgage may be beneficial.
Interest Rates: Fixed vs Variable
Interest rates play a significant role in your mortgage decision. After a period of aggressive rate hikes, the Bank of Canada began an easing cycle in late 2024/early 2025, bringing the overnight rate, which influences variable mortgage rates, to 2.75% by March 2025. Fixed-rate mortgages provide stability with consistent monthly payments, while variable-rate mortgages can fluctuate based on market conditions. In July 2024, borrowers opting for fixed-term mortgages mostly chose durations ranging from three years to less than five years, accounting for over half of all newly extended mortgages by chartered banks, while the share of newly extended mortgages with a variable interest rate fell to 9%. Understanding the implications of these rates is crucial when deciding between open or closed mortgages. A lower interest rate can save you a significant amount over the life of the loan, but it’s essential to weigh this against the flexibility you may need in the future. Whether you choose a fixed or variable rate, keep in mind how these rates interact with your choice of mortgage type.
Assessing Your Financial Stability and Long-Term Goals
Ultimately, the choice between open and closed mortgages hinges on your financial situation and personal preferences. Evaluate your current income, job stability, and future financial goals. Despite higher interest rates, Canada’s national mortgage delinquency rate remains historically low, at approximately 0.19% in Q2 2024, indicating that over 99% of Canadian mortgage holders are in good standing. However, early-stage delinquencies have started to rise and are expected to continue doing so in 2025, reflecting financial pressures on borrowers. A significant wave of mortgage renewals occurred in 2024, with approximately $251 billion in mortgages renewing at higher rates, and even more renewals slated for 2025 and 2026. The average monthly payment increase for renewing mortgages was estimated at between $400 and $500 for those renewing in 2024, with mortgage payments seeing the largest increase in minimum payment due amounts year-over-year at 13.5% as of Q2 2024. This highlights the importance of careful financial planning.
If you are someone who values flexibility and the ability to pay off your mortgage faster, an open mortgage may suit you best despite its higher interest rate. If you prefer lower monthly payments and are confident in your ability to meet the terms of a closed mortgage, it may be the right choice. Take the time to assess your circumstances, consult with a mortgage broker, and choose a mortgage that aligns with your financial future.
PHL’s Closed Products
PHL offers distinct closed rate options, specifically designed to provide clients with predictable payments and to reduce their initial costs. A key characteristic of PHL’s Closed Rate products is the simple, low-cost setup fee, which is paid at funding. This approach allows borrowers to bypass the larger, percentage-based lender fees typically associated with open mortgages. This structure provides clear up-front savings and a straightforward process with transparent costs and no hidden surprises. While these products are ideal for borrowers who are comfortable holding their loan to maturity, they also offer a predictable early payout mechanism: a penalty of three months’ interest if the loan is discharged early. This structured approach to fees and early payout differentiates PHL’s closed rates from both the higher initial costs of many open mortgages and the often more complex and potentially higher prepayment penalties found in conventional bank-issued closed mortgages.
How PHL Can Help
At PHL, we understand the importance of finding the right mortgage solution for your unique financial journey. We are dedicated to empowering financial success through transparent and reliable alternative mortgage solutions, building trust and lasting relationships. We offer innovative and transparent mortgage solutions that prioritize reliability and client satisfaction, providing a seamless experience with personalized guidance and competitive rates for various property types. Our open-term mortgage solutions offer flexibility and control, especially for those who value penalty-free prepayments. For investors, we provide access to high-quality, liquid mortgage investment opportunities with transparent information on risk management and capital preservation.
PHL empowers both mortgage brokers and investors. We serve as a reliable partner for mortgage brokers, offering innovative solutions and supporting their business growth. For investors, our experienced team and rigorous due diligence ensure secure and reliable investment opportunities in the Canadian mortgage market. As your trusted ally in the Canadian mortgage landscape, our team leverages decades of experience in real estate, finance, and underwriting, combined with an unwavering commitment to ethical practices and rigorous due diligence. We build long-term partnerships based on trust, transparency, and mutual respect. At PHL, we are committed to helping you achieve your financial goals and build a stronger financial future.
Connect With Us
If you would like to submit a deal directly, you can do so here.
Reach out to our team directly:
| 👤 BC & Alberta – Contact Kevin Cheng: | 👤 Ontario – Contact Julia Li: |
| 📧 [email protected] 📞 604-579-0846 | 📧 [email protected] 📞 416-649-8275 |
